Pinned

IQ vs. Rationality

I’ve read several books about decision-making this year. One of the best was What Intelligence Tests Miss. One day, I’ll write up in detail what I learned from the book, but for now I want to share some of what I found interesting. It distinguishes between IQ and rationality and explains that high IQ doesn’t equate to good decision-making.

One thing that stuck with me was what the author called “dysrationalia,” which is the inability to behave rationally despite having adequate intelligence.  

And what does rationality mean? Setting appropriate goals, taking the appropriate action given your goals and beliefs, and having beliefs that make sense given the available evidence.

You can be highly intelligent and still be irrational. This is because smart people can hold beliefs that aren’t grounded in reality and/or make decisions that don’t align with their goals. Said differently, you can be smart and still exercise poor judgment.

This book goes into a lot more detail about traps that lead to poor judgment. If you’re interested in understanding how smart people make bad decisions, you should consider giving this book a read.

Connected Entrepreneurs
No items found.
Connected Books
What Intelligence Tests Miss

2009

Framework

by

Keith E. Stanovich

2009

April 2026

A framework book that explains how rational thinking differs from IQ, and why rationality is more important. The book argues that IQ measures only part of human cognitive ability and doesn't measure the rational thinking skills that actually drive good decisions. The author introduces the concept of dysrationalia (smart people making stupid decisions) and builds a detailed taxonomy of reasoning errors that explains what causes those bad decisions and how to correct them. The most interesting of these are mindware gaps and contaminated mindware.